What is a rollover for business startups?
A rollover for business startups (ROBS) is an arrangement in which a new C corporation sponsors a retirement plan, the owner rolls retirement savings into it, and the plan uses that money to buy the company's stock. The company then spends the cash on the business.
The IRS says ROBS plans are not considered an abusive tax avoidance transaction. The same IRS page still calls them "questionable," because they may benefit only the one person who rolls over the money. Legal is not the same as safe.
Sellers often pitch ROBS 401(k) business financing as money without debt. There is no loan payment, that part is true. The risk moves into your retirement account instead, and the IRS notes that promoters market ROBS aggressively.
Commera is a broker, not a lender. We compare offers from our lender partners. Commera does not arrange or set up ROBS plans, does not recommend ROBS providers and is not paid by them.
This guide explains the IRS and Labor Department rules so you can ask sharper questions. It is not tax or legal advice. Consult a tax advisor and an ERISA attorney before any money moves.
How does a ROBS work, step by step?
A ROBS works in five steps, and the money never reaches you as a taxable withdrawal. A 2008 IRS memo to examiners, the IRS guidelines on rollovers as business start-ups, described the sequence like this:
- You form a C corporation. At first it has no employees, assets or operations.
- The corporation adopts a qualified retirement plan. The plan document lets participants invest their balances in employer stock.
- You move savings from a prior employer's plan into the new plan. This is done by rollover or by direct trustee-to-trustee transfer.
- The plan buys the corporation's stock with that money.
- The corporation uses the cash to buy a franchise or start another business.
The same memo notes that franchises are often the business of choice. Promoters market the design online as a funding method.
Why is there no tax at the start? The money moves from one tax-deferred account to another. The memo says the income tax that would apply to a distribution is avoided.
IRS Topic 558 confirms that a distribution you roll over is not subject to the 10% additional tax. That holds only if every rule is met.
Using a 401(k) to buy a business through ROBS has one twist. In the IRS description, you do not buy the business yourself. The corporation that your plan owns buys it, and you run it as an employee. For the other ways to pay for a deal, see how to finance buying a business.
What rules do the IRS and DOL apply to a ROBS?
A ROBS plan follows the IRS and Department of Labor rules for any qualified retirement plan. It also follows the rules on a plan that holds employer stock. The table sums up the main ones, each with its source.
| Rule | What it means for you | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Adequate consideration | The plan may buy employer stock only at fair market value set in good faith. A thin appraisal can turn the purchase into a prohibited transaction. | ERISA §408(e) and §3(18), per the 2008 IRS memo |
| No prohibited transactions | The plan cannot sell, exchange or lend with a party in interest. The employer and its owners count as parties in interest. | IRC §4975, ERISA §406, DOL |
| Fiduciary duty | Whoever runs the plan must act solely in the interest of participants. Duties must be carried out prudently. | DOL |
| Nondiscrimination | Amending the plan to keep later employees out may violate Code qualification rules. | IRS ROBS project |
| Annual Form 5500 | The one-participant filing exception does not apply to a ROBS plan. | IRS ROBS project |
| Form 1099-R and Form 1120 | A Form 1099-R should be issued for the rollover. The C corporation files Form 1120. | IRS ROBS project |
| Determination letter | A favorable letter covers the plan's written terms. It gives no protection for how you operate the plan. | IRS ROBS project |
The Form 5500 point trips many owners. Per the IRS ROBS compliance project, promoters wrongly told some sponsors that a one-participant exception for plans under $250,000 removed the filing. The IRS says the exception does not apply. The plan, through its stock, owns the business, not you.
Form 5500 is filed electronically through the EFAST2 system, per the Department of Labor. That filing comes due every year the plan exists.
The prohibited transaction rules are written into two laws. ERISA §406 bars a fiduciary from causing a sale, exchange or loan between the plan and a party in interest. The DOL guide to fiduciary responsibilities lists the employer and statutorily defined owners among those parties. In a ROBS, that is you and your company.
What can go wrong with a ROBS?

The main risk of a ROBS is losing both the business and the retirement savings that paid for it. The IRS ROBS Project found that, despite some success stories, most ROBS businesses either failed or were on the road to failure.
The IRS findings cite high rates of business and personal bankruptcy. They also cite liens and corporate dissolutions. Some owners lost savings built over many years, and the business with them.
Much of the money was gone early. Per the IRS, in many cases savings were depleted before the business began to offer its product or service. In some cases large recurring promoter fees or legal issues were a factor.
Taxes add a second layer. Under IRC §4975, a prohibited transaction triggers a tax of 15% of the amount involved for each year in the taxable period. If the transaction is not corrected within that period, §4975(b) adds a tax of 100% of the amount involved.
Disqualification is the third layer. Per the IRS, a plan run in a discriminatory way, or one that makes prohibited transactions, can be disqualified. That can bring "adverse tax consequences" for the sponsor and its participants.
The 2008 IRS memo found significant disqualifying operational defects in most of the plans it examined. In some plans, employees were not told about the plan. Stock was not valued, or was valued with threadbare appraisals. Some required annual reports were not filed.
Consult a tax advisor and an ERISA attorney before you sign with any provider. Ask who values the stock each year. Ask who files Form 5500, the annual return the IRS expects, and what the fees add up to over time.
Worked example: four routes to startup cash
Only a ROBS and a term loan deliver the full amount in cash, in this Commera illustrative calculation. A cash withdrawal leaves $132,000 after tax. A plan loan is capped by IRS limits.
Methodology: Commera illustrative calculation, not an offer and not tax advice. The owner is 45 and holds a vested 401(k) from a former employer. The whole withdrawal is taxed at a flat 24%, the 2026 federal rate for single filers over $105,700 per the IRS 2026 inflation adjustments. No state tax is modeled.
The owner is under 59½, so the 10% additional tax applies, per IRS Topic 558. The plan loan rate of 9.00% is an assumption: bank prime of 7.00% per Federal Reserve H.15, plus 2 points. ROBS provider fees are not modeled. The IRS treats them as a separate risk.
| Route | Cash available, $ | Tax at the start, $ | Repayment | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash withdrawal | 132,000 | 68,000 (48,000 income tax + 20,000 additional tax) | None | Taxes, lost savings |
| 401(k) plan loan | 50,000 | 0 | 60 payments of 1,037.92 at an assumed 9.00% | Plan may not offer loans, 5-year limit |
| ROBS | 200,000 | 0 if every rule is met | None, the plan owns stock | Whole balance in one private company, annual Form 5500 |
| Term loan | 200,000 | 0 | See the next worked example | Monthly payment, personal guaranty |
The withdrawal is the costly route. In this illustrative case, $68,000 goes to tax before you spend anything on the business.
The plan loan has hard limits. Per the IRS plan loan FAQ, the maximum is the greater of $10,000 or 50% of the vested balance, capped at $50,000. The same FAQ says repayment must occur within 5 years, in substantially equal payments made at least quarterly. A plan may offer loans, but it is not required to.
The ROBS keeps every dollar working. It also puts every dollar into the stock of one private company.
Worked example: ROBS or a term loan over five years

Over five years, a ROBS has no payments but gives up an assumed $67,645 of account growth. A term loan of the same size costs $65,909.08 in interest and fees, in this Commera illustrative calculation.
Methodology: Commera illustrative calculation, not a loan offer and not a real deal. The term loan has an assumed 11.00% fixed rate and 60 monthly payments. A 2.5% origination fee is withheld at funding, so $195,000 arrives.
Est. APR in this illustrative case is the IRR of the monthly payments against that net amount. For the ROBS, the forgone growth assumes the balance would earn 6% a year inside the 401(k). That rate is an assumption, not a forecast.
ROBS provider fees are not modeled in this illustrative comparison.
| Item | ROBS | Term loan |
|---|---|---|
| Amount, $ | 200,000 | 200,000 |
| Interest rate, % | n/a | 11.00 fixed (assumed) |
| Origination fee, $ | Provider fees not modeled | 5,000 (2.5%, withheld) |
| Term, months | n/a | 60 |
| Monthly payment, $ | 0 | 4,348.48 |
| Total repayment, $ | 0 | 260,909.08 |
| Cost, $ | Growth given up, 67,645 (assumed 6% a year) | 65,909.08 (interest 60,909.08 + fee) |
| Est. APR, % | n/a | 12.11 (IRR on 195,000 net) |
| If the business fails | Savings tied to the stock can be lost | Debt and guaranty remain, 401(k) intact |
In this illustrative case, the interest rate is not the APR. Once the fee is counted, the fixed rate becomes an est. APR of about 12.11%. All terms are subject to underwriting, and each lender sets its own pricing.
The loan figures sit inside the ranges on Commera's business term loans page. Per that page, term-loan amounts start at $25,000, modeled origination fees run 0% to 5%, and terms run 12 to 60 months.
Be clear about one limit. The same Commera page says term loans usually fit businesses with 2+ years of history and consistent revenue. A brand-new startup may not meet that bar.
In this illustrative comparison, the real difference shows up if the business fails. With a ROBS, the savings tied to the stock can be lost. With a loan, the debt and the guaranty remain, but the 401(k) stays intact. If you already run a business, check your funding options before you decide.
When does a ROBS make sense, and when should you skip it?
A ROBS is worth discussing with a tax advisor when your retirement does not depend on this one account and you can run a plan and a C corporation. The business plan should also be tested first.
Raise it with your advisor if:
- You have other retirement savings or cash outside this account.
- You are ready to run a qualified plan and a C corporation, with annual filings and stock valuations.
- Someone with no stake in the deal has checked your business plan.
Skip it if:
- This account is your whole retirement.
- You have no time or budget for plan reporting.
- You need only part of the money, and a plan loan or other financing can cover it.
The trade-off is close to using home equity to fund a business. In both cases a personal asset goes on the line for a business bet.
Buying an existing company changes the picture. Read how to buy a business, then compare a ROBS with a business acquisition loan.
Broker disclosure: Commera Finance is a broker, not a direct lender. Financing providers make their own eligibility, underwriting, approval, pricing, and term decisions.
Sources
- IRS, Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project
- IRS, Guidelines regarding rollovers as business start-ups, memorandum of October 1, 2008
- IRC §4975, Tax on prohibited transactions, Cornell LII
- ERISA §406, 29 U.S.C. §1106, Prohibited transactions, Cornell LII
- U.S. Department of Labor, EBSA, Meeting your fiduciary responsibilities
- U.S. Department of Labor, EBSA, Form 5500 series
- IRS, Topic no. 558, Additional tax on early distributions from retirement plans other than IRAs
- IRS, Retirement plans FAQs regarding loans
- IRS, Tax inflation adjustments for tax year 2026
- Federal Reserve, H.15 Selected Interest Rates, bank prime loan rate
- Commera Finance, Business loans
